Leave A Whisper:
(segmented
chapter reviews)
* Simply remarkable. Your use of metaphors really
speaks out to the reader. The characters are crisp and the story line top notch.
--mswritealot/fanstory
Comment Written
18-Nov-2005
* Very good description at the beginning. It
made me sick, which is the response you want given the material. The poetry and transitions are very ingenious and add a unique
flavor to your writing. The tempo, narration, and character development were all excellent. Very well done.
--eborchert/fanstory
Comment Written 18-Nov-2005
* Excellent opening.
Really liked the setting and the feeling that you created with this. I also loved the way there was such a clear difference
between his thoughts and his actions. The following sequences were great also, revealing enough to keep the reader interested
but not too much. Will be reading on and good luck with publishing.
--thgrrl/fanstory
Comment Written 11-Nov-2005
* This is probably the most unique thing I've read since I've been here. It's
very witty and aware of itself and you are a writer who is very sure of her ability to tell this story. Very well done.
--Thalisa/fanstory
Comment Written 11-Nov-2005
* I like the reserved,
structured, organized narrative fancy expressiveness with the blend of suspense, light spark of horror, nice flow of subject,
theme, plot, characterization with the thrill top to bottom with captivating beginning in
mystery with automatic flow
and end poetic curious. A pleasant thrill-packed read.
--Daniel Ray/fanstory
Comment Written 10-Nov-2005
* I like your writing. I found that you have a directness that captures my imagination and
carries me forward to enjoy your every word. I think you have created a plausible paradigm and I will continue to watch for
your writings in the
future. I will read on.
--Balladeer/fnastory
Comment Written 10-Apr-2005
* This is an amazing book. It draws the reader into the scenes and makes them feel as if
they are watching the events as they happen. Excellent.
--Wendyanne/fanstory
Comment Written 10-Apr-2005
* This is so creepy, I love it! I'm adding it to my bookcase so I can read the previous
chapters as well. I like the first part where you are showing the attackers perspective and thoughts. This sounds like a real
book you'd find in a bookstore.
Great job!
--PrettyPoetress/fanstory
Comment Written 26-Mar-2005
* If I could write like you do, I'd be a best selling author by now. You don't need
to be here Jannie, you need to be on Oprah's book club. You know, one thing I've been thinking about re: weird coincidences
with this book is that "Stigmata" a condition thought to a prevalent sign of saint hood among Catholics is usually
manifested in blood appearing at the hands and feet (areas of the wounds of crucifixion-actually incorrect if you know biology).
Anyway, one of the most
interesting aspects of the condition as it coincides with this story is that the blood smells
of "roses." Sorry, my incredibly silly mind on wacky tangents as I was thinking about the rose petals in the hands
and that Toni likes the smell of roses
(which is connected as I mentioned before, I believe with Mary and other saints)
First, allow me to humbly apologize with not having kept up with this amazing book of yours. Second, let me just say JANNIE
BALLIET is a (expletive) GENIUS!!! Did I remember to mention how much I love this book? Okay enough of that nonsense,
I'm actually stalling (I feel like a gymnist on the balance bar) because I'm just running out of ways to say; "Damn
Jannie, but you're one heck of a great writer!" So, let's just say "Good how" and leave it at that.
I am awed by your talent and jealous of as well.Its fun to go through the book and bug you with review after review... Ah,
the method of my madness. I get it now-You're like one of those Muslim carpet weavers in Morocco who purposefully place
a slight flaw in each carpet they weave so as not to insult God. So, Reddick, a man who feels that the only way to enjoy himself
sexually, and preserve what he feels is the purity of his victims is to destroy them-- crucifying each one in an attempt to
offer an atonement for his sins ( or his mother's) perhaps? A raging sociopath desperate for attention, yet in reality,
a craven coward.As much as he desires the attention (and fear his acts generate-that fear giving them a sense of power they
feel is denied them in real life). Interesting that these guys so desperate desire to be known for their "art" yet,
do what they can to hide all the same-catch me if you can (Oh please dont/Do let them catch me) ...And my kids wonder why
I had to quit watching Profiler and Millennium! Okay, had not planned on writing a review but- DAYUM Girl if you don't
know how to set the stage. You should be writing screenplays- We might actually see something decent come out of Hollywood
then. Your writing is like a meal set out by a master chef: You know it's going to taste like heaven, and its just so
beautiful you don't want to spoil it with something as vulgar as eating. I'm sitting here reading this. How does one
judge perfection? What can I do but offer my voice, feeble as it is to what are already legions of your fans singing your
praises? You have a gift for poetry that could easily rival Tolkein himself. If I could write half as well, I'd be writing
half as well. But that would be something indeed.
--Hokeysmoke/fanstory
Comment Written 22-Mar-2005
* How do you do it? I'm sucked in to reading all the chapters. The writing is good
and the story line seems to be moving along just nicely. I like these kinds of stories, they draw a person in. I really like
it. I'm going to continue to read each chapter. I love the way you visualize the surroundings, you are definitely showing
and not telling. I'm trying to show instead of tell, it's kind of hard for me, for some reason... But anyway, I think
your writing is very, very good.
--Nickles/fanstory
Comment Written 22-Mar-2005
* I see your book starts with a psychopath who murders and rapes women and thinks he's a artist and a poet. It
looks like a book that public would love, and it also appears that you don't have any trouble finding reviewers. I'll
be reading
more. Thought I would become more familiar with the writings of those who have read more than five chapters
of my book. This looks like a scary book, but I've read John Grisham's "A Time To Kill", and I'm guessing
I can take the time to read your book, too.
--Tweedypie/fanstory
Comment Written 21-Mar-2005
* It's really a story that keeps my interest and every chapter leaves you wanting more. I wish I could just read
it all at once.
--Moonchild/fanstory
Comment Written 08-Mar-2005
*
I'm going to brag someday that I read this before it became a published book! Great job. Suspense just keeps building.
You've really described this guy in a way that would give anyone the creeps. Really captivating. Interesting to introduce
a new character-I'm sure I'll have to keep reading to find out who she is and why she's at the lawyer office.
I like the way you weave pertinent song lyrics into the writing. Tight, gripping suspense! Nice combination of narrative and
dialogue. You've got the hook buried. You've nailed down the reader and hooked me. Naturally, I've book cased
this and am moving on to every chapter. Excellent write. No mistakes, lots of suspense..keep it going. I hope the publisher
awards you the contract!
--johnnyb/fanstory
Comment Written 07-Mar-2005
*
Snappy writing style. Great hook in opening. I like this. You've given me enough snitches of this in that in your setup
to pull yank me into this tale, and make me want to head for the next chapter like an out of control freight train. More.
I want more! And keep up the brisk pace which shows up almost everywhere so far. Great job!
--flashwriter/fanstory
Comment Written
20-Feb-2005
* Well, first thing I thought...uhhuh, serial killer?
Not another serial killer story... but your description is great. The characterizations...oh WOW...the characterization...
fantastic. Especially the hideous rapist and killer.
--ladykay/fanstory
Comment Written 23-Mar-2005
* A hunter with a poetic streak... The more I read, the more the images get stronger in my
mind. And I love the clear yet clipped length of each. Just enough to get the essence, and then on to the next page... The
artist feels a need to sign the work he's created... Wow, this oozes intensity! I really like the style and tone of this
chapter. A very characteristic detective, with a bit of timidness, (I like that...lol), a psychic that's psyched out,
and a serial killer that's not two dimensional... hmmm, a good brew, it seems... I can easily see this as a film script!
I'm sure you've thought this
already... This would make a fine film...You have me hooked! I've book cased
the chapters and have to keep reading. Coming from law enforcement background I'm anxious to find what makes Reddick "more
than the typical serial killer" -Great!- Every page, well, I'm getting tired of praising your work here. It's
damn good work and I've got nothing else to say!
--void-is/fanstory
Comment Written 16-Feb-2005
* Again
this flows very well. It is a great story. I'm having fun reading it. This is the first I have ever read of a book of
yours...only poetry up to now. I must say... you take on a whole different persona with this thriller stuff , don't you.
Hmmm. This is a very good story you are working on... Good work as usual.
--Mastery/fanstory
Comment Written 13-Feb-2005
* Just read this segment. It moves right along and makes me want to read more. I'll have
to go back and start at the beginning though, since I've been off line and pretty busy lately.
--Termite/fanstory
Comment Written
13-Feb-2005
*This was good, really good. I liked how it progressed, moving
from character to character. It left me wondering (and eager to see) where and how it would all be tied together. It had a
good flow to it, and I liked the insertions of poetry to each sections with the killer. Nice job.
--driven/fanstory
Comment Written 20-Feb-2005
* Gosh, I hope you are able to reach some kind of agreement with the publisher because this
is a book that will SELL. It's riveting, with the realistic feel of the character taking the reader into his life ...
whether he wants to be there or not.
Shivery good stuff!
--Gayle/fanstory
Comment Written 13-Feb-2005
* Once again you've written an amazing book. It's really cool how you wrote this,
getting into the mind of the criminal... well done. Keep it up. Very vivid and very realistic and plausible. Well done.
I loved the description the most, very well done. Awesome writing.
-
--Lpspider/fanstory
Comment Written 17-Feb-2005
* Very powerful writing. I really like the way the story started and is laying out. Your
characters have gained a great deal of depth in a short amount of time. I get the feeling that Reddick won't be discouraged
by the minor coverage of the media's news story. I will read more. I saw nothing I would change. Nice job.
--Night Stalker/fanstory
Comment Written 22-Feb-2005